With just 16 voters, it didn't take much more than a single Top 10 vote for a film to make the Top 10 here, and the big winner here (and it was a bit of a blowout for the top spot) still only managed two first-place votes. Regardless, it's a fine list, with a mixture of old and new, spread against multiple styles of animation.
Here are your winners (1st place votes in parentheses):

10. Sleeping Beauty - 24 points from 3 voters (1)

8. Aladdin - 25 points from 3 voters (0)

8. Beauty and the Beast - 28 points from 4 voters (1)

7. Spirited Away - 31 points from 4 voters (1)

6. Fantasia - 33 points from 6 voters (2)

5. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 34 points from 5 voters (1)

4. The Incredibles - 36 points from 6 votes (1)

3. The Nightmare Before Christmas - 40 points from 6 votes (1)

2. The Lion King - 44 points from 7 votes (0)

1. Toy Story - 63 points from 10 votes (2)
So...how many did you vote for? If you'd like to see yours and all the other votes, scroll down. A post has been added with all of them, but I have dated it prior to this post so it won't clutter the page.
Others receiving 1st-place votes: Finding Nemo, Kirikou And The Sorceress, Pinocchio, The Prince of Egypt, The Triplets of Belleville, and Wall*E.
Finally, with 2 votes, Documentaries have been chosen as the next genre to tackle. The poll is already up, and will be for two weeks - be sure to read the instructions. Go vote now so I don't have to hassle you later! Thanks.
One final note - I've heard that Mister Poll doesn't get along well with Internet Explorer 8. If you are having troubles, please try Firefox or Safari.
http://www.misterpoll.com/polls/361075